The World Forum - Political Forums

Nonpartisan political forums. Political blogs. International news.

Discuss and debate political, cultural, social and environmental issues.

submit story | sections | topics | your account | help/FAQ | contact | links | search | RSS
] International %% Africa %% Asia %% Australia/Oceania Europe %% North America %% South America %% Blogs %% Site Talk ]

 UN Report Says No Genocide In Darfur


War & Terror

By Drog (Canada), Section Sudan
Posted on Mon Jan 31, 2005 at 01:19:38 PM PST

The long-awaited United Nations report is in, and has concluded that the Sudanese government has not been committing genocide in the country's Darfur region, where tens of thousands of civilians have died in a nearly two-year crisis.

It was last October that Annan established a five-member independent commission whose mandate was to "investigate reports of violations of international humanitarian law and human rights law in Darfur by all parties, to determine also whether or not acts of genocide have occurred, and to identify the perpetrators of such violations with a view to ensuring that those responsible are held accountable."

According to CBC News, the report has not yet been made public, but Sudan's foreign minister said that his government had received a copy in advance. Although the report stops short of using the word "genocide" -- a word that the United States used to describe the Sudanese Darfur campaign, and a word which compels specific reactions under international law -- it does strongly criticize the role the Sudanese government played in not stopping the killings and rapes of Darfur residents by armed Arab militiamen called Janjaweed.

According to the UN News Centre, the report arrived at UN Headquarters in New York on January 27. After the report is read by Secretary-General Kofi Annan, it should be sent to the Sudanese Government, which will have three days to respond, before it will be delivered most likely early this week to the members of the Security Council.

As reported by Reuters, genocide is legally defined by international conventions as the "intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group".

Jan Pronk, the UN's special envoy to Sudan, estimates that more than 100,000 people have died in the past year, most through hunger and disease caused by their displacement and poor conditions in the camps.

Annan said on Sunday that "gross violations of human rights" had occurred in Darfur and recommended the Security Council consider sanctions on the oil-exporting country. The motion to impose sanctions on Khartoum last year was blocked by China, which has oil interests in Sudan, and Russia, which supplies arms.

The United States is considering a new UN resolution that would impose an arms embargo and sanctions against those responsible for gross human rights abuses. Sudanese Foreign Minister Mustafa Osman Ismail said that "sanctions will not help Darfur".

The United Nations has proposed trying Darfur's suspected war criminals at the International Criminal Court, but the U.S. opposes that idea because they do not recognize that tribunal.


Help create the world's greatest international forum. Tell the world what you think about this story — get your free account and post your comments.

What's your opinion?
Welcome to our discussion below!
(Free signup required to post comments.)

Advertisement

Coming soon!

The world could use more dialogue about its differences — a little understanding goes a long way. There are many online forums where people with different perspectives yell at each other and hurl abuse. There aren't so many where completely different points of view are expressed rationally and constructively. That's why The World Forum was created.
Display: Sort:
Darfur rebels say it 'was' genocide (none / 0) (#1)
by Drog (Canada) on Tue Feb 01, 2005 at 06:55:59 AM PST

Reuters reports that rebels from the Darfur region of western Sudan say that the UN report was mistaken in failing to accuse the Sudan government and allied Arab militias of genocide in the Darfur conflict.

"If this report says there is no genocide in Darfur then we reject this report," said Khalil Ibrahim, leader of the Justice and Equality Movement (JEM).

"There are hundreds of mass graves that the commission did not go to," he said, adding that the decision to stop short of a genocide finding was politically motivated.

Leader Abdel Wahed Mohamed al-Nur of the main rebel group, the Sudan Liberation Movement (SLM), said the report was incomplete because UN investigators did not have access to areas where the worst fighting took place.

World Forum Poll

Do you think the Sudanese Darfur campaign should have been labelled as "genocide"?
Yes
No
I don't know

Votes: 2
Results | Other Polls


Login

Username:
Password:

Signup to post comments, to vote on story submissions and to set preferences.

create account | faq | search