The World Forum - Political Forums

Nonpartisan political forums. Political blogs. International news.

Discuss and debate political, cultural, social and environmental issues.

submit story | sections | topics | your account | help/FAQ | contact | links | search | RSS
] International %% Africa %% Asia %% Australia/Oceania Europe %% North America %% South America %% Blogs %% Site Talk ]

 Redefining Tolerance In The Netherlands


Religion

By Drog (Canada), Section Netherlands
Posted on Mon Mar 14, 2005 at 10:31:55 AM PST

Ayaan Hirsi Ali has come a long way since she sought asylum in Holland as a 22-year-old woman fleeing an arranged marriage. She worked hard at menial jobs in factories and hotels, attended university where she took political science, and now sits as an elected member of parliament for the Liberal Party. Her portfolio, as she explains in a BBC interview, includes the migration of non-Western migrants to the Netherlands, the emancipation of women, and development aid to developing countries.

She is seen as a kind of star in Holland, but many regard her as a traitor to Islam, which she rejected as a very young woman. She has been an outspoken critic of the way Islam treats women, has called the prophet Mohammed a "perverted tyrant", and has accused part of the Koran as being "a license for oppression." She shook up Dutch politics by pointing to the blind spots in the Netherland's tolerant society, such as "honor killings" -- the murder of Muslim women who stray from the faith.

She was forced to go into hiding for three months when Dutch film-maker Theo van Gogh was murdered, allegedly by a Muslim radical, after making the controversial movie "Submission" about a Muslim woman forced into an arranged marriage who is abused by her husband and raped by her uncle. The film was written by Hirsi Ali, and she has received numerous death threats for it. In January, she returned to parliament, though still living in hiding with round-the-clock security.

Hirsi Ali was recently interviewed by Morley Safer on 60 Minutes, in which she talked about her views on the Muslim faith and how the Dutch society deals with it.

"My accusation towards the Dutch society was, 'You think you are tolerant, but if you look behind those curtains in Amsterdam and Rotterdam, there are women who are abused. There are women who are taken to Morocco and Turkey and are killed there. They're murdered. And there are no records of those murders,' " says Hirsi Ali.

"I suppose some people would say we can't impose our alien laws on these new citizens," says Safer.

"That was the definition of tolerance before I came," says Hirsi Ali. "And now we are redefining that by saying, freeing these women, giving them a chance at life is not imposing Dutch will, or let's say Dutch values, on others. But it's protecting these individuals."

Hirsi Ali says she intends to make a sequel to Submission, called "Shortcut to Enlightenment". "By not making 'Submission Part II,' I would only be helping terrorists believe that if they use violence, they're rewarded with what they want," she says.


The world could use more dialogue about its differences — a little understanding goes a long way. There are many online forums where people with different perspectives yell at each other and hurl abuse. There aren't so many where completely different points of view are expressed rationally and constructively. That's why The World Forum was created.

Tell the world what YOU think about this story. You can post anonymously now by clicking on the "Post A Comment" link below, or sign up for your free account first, so that your chosen username appears next to your comments.

What's your opinion?
Welcome to our discussion below!
(Free signup required to post comments.)

Advertisement

Coming soon!

The world could use more dialogue about its differences — a little understanding goes a long way. There are many online forums where people with different perspectives yell at each other and hurl abuse. There aren't so many where completely different points of view are expressed rationally and constructively. That's why The World Forum was created.
Display: Sort:

World Forum Poll

Do you think Hirsi Ali should make Submission 2?
Yes.
Yes, but not yet.
No.
Not sure.

Votes: 9
Results | Other Polls


Login

Username:
Password:

Signup to post comments, to vote on story submissions and to set preferences.

create account | faq | search