![]() |
Nonpartisan political forums. Political blogs. International news.Discuss and debate political, cultural, social and environmental issues. |
| submit story | sections | topics | your account | help/FAQ | contact | links | search | RSS | |
| International | Africa | Asia | Australia/Oceania | Europe | North America | South America | Blogs | Site Talk |
|
By Drog (Canada), Section International
A National Academy of Sciences report (.pdf) last year said that while the milk and meat from cloned animals would not likely make anyone sick, more research should be performed. Now, a new US-Japan study published in the April 11 online issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences says that milk and meat from cloned cattle does indeed appear to meet industry standards and appears to be safe for human consumption.
As BBC News reports, the scientists, led by Professor Jerry Yang from the University of Connecticut, compared the produce from two beef and four dairy clones, all derived from a single Holstein dairy cow and a single Japanese black bull, with the produce from normal animals of similar age and breed.
The meat was analysed against more than 100 physiological, tissue and cellular components, while the milk was analysed for protein, fat and other variables. No significant differences between the produce of cloned and normal cattle were found. Higher levels of fat and fatty acids were found in the cloned cow meat, but they still fell within beef industry standards. While the study showed the cloned produce to be within the range approved for human consumption, the scientists stressed that the research was still in its early stages. Their findings, they said, provide "guidelines" for further research with larger numbers of clones from different genetic backgrounds.
Cloning livestock may one day increase yields by copying those animals that are especially productive especially resistant to disease.
"The milking production levels in the US are three to four times higher than levels in China; maybe even five times or more compared to cows in India and some other countries," Professor Jerry Yang told BBC News. "Therefore cloning could offer technology for duplicating superior farm animals. However, all the products from these cloned animals must be safe for human consumption. ...and it is a major issue for scientists to provide a scientific basis for the data and information to address this question."
As USA Today reports, there is currently no law governing the sale of meat or milk from the estimated 1,000 to 2,000 cloned farm animals in the USA. But since 2003, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has asked producers to voluntarily keep the meat and milk of these animals, and that of their offspring, out of the food supply.
Wired News reports that companies like ViaGen and Cyagra, which offer livestock-cloning services, have also been waiting for several years for a final say from the FDA.
"For the United States agricultural industry, (cloning) can reduce the number of cows necessary for milking," said Jerry Yang "They can have a pleasant environment and produce even more milk." He also said that cloning the cattle from United States, where genetic breeding is more advanced, could save developing countries 50 years of breeding.
The idea of cloning animals for human consumption is not without its critics. First, there are the welfare concerns, as most cloned animals do not make it to term before being born, and many of those that do are born deformed or prone to illness. The Humane Society of the United States has asked for a ban on milk and meat from clones for just this reason. Second, there is still the concern that healthy clones may have subtle defects that could make their food products unsafe to eat.
As the Washington Post reports, some critics are asking why it is necessary to clone cows that produce huge amounts of milk when surpluses, rather than shortages, are the main problem facing the U.S. dairy industry today.
There was also a surplus of milk back when Monsanto introduced their genetically engineered recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone (rBGH) to the marketplace a couple of years ago. It is reported to have caused all sorts of problems. The dairy cows became much more susceptible to udder infections called mastitis, resulting in pus in the milk, and great pain for the cows. Those cows must be treated with antibiotics, which of course make their way into the milk that we drink. That is a matter for public concern, especially when resistance to antibiotics is becoming a major health issue for us all. Could the cloning of cattle be another example of a risky, high-tech solution in need of a problem? Advertisement
The world could use more dialogue about its differences — a little understanding goes a long way. There are many online forums where people with different perspectives yell at each other and hurl abuse. There aren't so many where completely different points of view are expressed rationally and constructively. That's why The World Forum was created.
Cloned Cattle's Milk And Meat Seem Safe, Study Says | 0 comments ( topical, 0 hidden)
|
World Forum Poll
Top StoriesEli Lilly Under Fire over ZyprexaHealth & Medicine by DannyHaszard, August 22 Federal Judge comment on Eli Lilly Zyprexa Crime & Punishment by DannyHaszard, July 25 2 comments Eli Lilly reaping Zyprexa whirlwind Crime & Punishment by DannyHaszard, July 7 1 comment CHILD ABUSE JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES Human Rights by Mary, May 25 10 comments Jehovah's Witnesses Crisis of Conscience Human Rights by DannyHaszard, May 6 4 comments Eli Lilly STALLING on ZYPREXA Payouts Health & Medicine by DannyHaszard, May 2 Eli Lilly ZYPREXA Chronicles Health & Medicine by DannyHaszard, April 29 Eli Lilly Zyprexa Patients Thinking Sales Shrinking Health & Medicine by DannyHaszard, October 19 5 comments Eli Lilly Zyprexa SEQUEL Health & Medicine by DannyHaszard, September 11 Eli Lilly ZYPREXA STORM Health & Medicine by DannyHaszard, June 29 9 comments More stories... BlogsHamas Is Perpetrating The death of its PeopleDiary by clhrf - January 4 New Year Wishes & the wickedness of Vengeance Diary by clhrf - December 31 The Lebanese People: Faith, Hope & Perseverance Diary by clhrf - December 2 1 comment Data Entry Services from Cosoft The World Forum by cosoft7890 - November 12 1 comment Data Entry Services from Cosoft The World Forum by cosoft7890 - November 12 1 comment Rogue States & Terrorists Respond Only To Force &... Diary by clhrf - November 6 1 comment Lebanon's refugees in Israel & the Lebanese Leaders'... Diary by clhrf - October 21 2 comments October 13, & Lebanon's Heroes Diary by clhrf - October 11 Custom Paper Writing Diary by theone - September 29 The Future Started Yesterday Announcements by lrs - September 20 2 comments More blogs... Related Links+ report+ Proceeding s of the National Academy of Sciences + BBC News reports + Professor Jerry Yang + Holstein + USA Today reports + Food and Drug Administra tion (FDA) + Wired News reports + ViaGen + Cyagra + Washington Post reports + Monsanto + recombinan t Bovine Growth Hormone (rBGH) + caused all sorts of problems + More on Health & Medicine + Also by Drog |
||||||